Why Some Animals (and People) Just Aren’t Meant to Coexist—And That’s Okay
There was no sugarcoating it.
It wasn’t a gentle “no, thank you” or a subtle tail flick. It was a full-blown, ears-back, guttural growl of feline protest. A hiss with a capital H. A royal declaration from one Queen cat to another:
“NO. I don’t like you. I don’t want you. I will NOT share my kingdom.”
Let me back up a moment and set the scene.
Many of you know my youngest daughter, Karen. Yes, that Karen—Dr. Karen Shaw Becker, the most followed veterinarian on social media, tireless animal advocate, and founder of the first functional medicine vet hospital in the U.S. She’s loved by many, challenged by others, and respected by nearly everyone in the animal health world for one reason: her unapologetic commitment to do what’s best for animals—even when it ruffles a few feathers (or fur).
About six years ago, Karen and I did something we’ve done many times throughout our lives: we stood in our driveway, looked toward the sky, and asked for help.
This time, it was simple. We said:
“Dear God and Universe, we have a good home. If there’s a cat who needs one, send them our way.”
And the Universe, in its usual humorous style, replied with: “Here you go—take TWO.”
Enter the Queens: Bea and Callie
A week after our prayer, a friend at church approached me with a story. Two senior cats—sisters—had been surrendered to a large Phoenix shelter after their owner passed away. Her final wish? That the girls be adopted together.
Karen and I were moved. Seniors. Sisters. Alone in a shelter. We didn’t hesitate.
The shelter, as it turns out, was housed in a repurposed city jail. Not exactly cozy, but the staff was warm and welcoming. We walked in expecting cats. We walked out two hours later holding royalty—Bea and Callie, a pair of aging, opinionated Queen cats with very different dispositions.
And thus began our adventure.
From Shelter to Showdown
We soon learned that Bea and Callie’s sisterhood had always been a bit... strained.
Bea was the older cat—dominant, possessive, and deeply bonded to their late owner. Callie, a younger and gentler soul, had come into the home a few years later and never fully integrated into Bea’s world. In fact, shelter staff told us Callie spent most of her life hiding—in a pillowcase.
That’s not a metaphor. A literal pillowcase. It was her sanctuary. Her shield. Her quiet, soft escape from Bea’s constant reminders that she was not welcome.
When the cats arrived at our home, their ages were about 10 and 7. Karen, thankfully, knew exactly what to do. She immediately separated them. Callie was set up in the quiet corner of Karen’s closet, where she could decompress without threat or pressure. The pillowcase came with her—but once Karen felt she was ready to move on, it quietly disappeared. And to our relief, Callie never looked back.
Bea, meanwhile, made herself at home in the rest of the house—and made it known, loudly and repeatedly, that she wanted no part of this “sisterhood” arrangement.
Callie’s Quiet Confidence (and Homer’s Helping Paw)
Then, an unexpected hero joined the story.
We had recently adopted Homer, a soft-hearted, shy rescue dog who had spent most of his life in a nursing home with his elderly guardian. We’re pretty sure Homer had never seen a cat before—because his first instinct when confronted by Bea’s hissing fury was to… avert his eyes.
Bea letting Homer know he wasn’t welcome in the hallway
It was a brilliant strategy, actually. Homer’s refusal to react seemed to de-escalate the tension in the home. He ignored Bea completely. And Callie? Well, something in Homer’s gentle presence seemed to embolden her. Slowly, she began creeping out of her closet hideaway. A sniff here. A sunbeam there.
Callie and Homer formed an unspoken alliance: two quiet souls sharing space with minimal fuss.
Bea, however, didn’t change. She continued to demand her solo reign, staking out doorways and hissing with royal authority at anything that dared challenge her rule.
It was clear—we had two Queens, and only one castle.
Aunt Jo to the Rescue
Thankfully, help came in the form of my sister, Jo. A lifelong animal lover and experienced foster mom, Jo lived just two blocks away. When she heard about Bea’s unhappiness, she didn’t hesitate.
“Bring her to me,” she said. “Let’s see what happens.”
What happened was magic.
Within days of arriving at Aunt Jo’s house, Bea softened. Her growl softened to a purr. She found the peace and undivided attention she had craved all along. And at last, her true personality emerged—affectionate, loyal, even a little silly.
Bea Kitty, ruler of Aunt Jo’s house
Back at our home, the change was just as dramatic. The tension lifted. Callie’s confidence blossomed. She and Homer grew even closer, and our home settled into a peaceful, three-species rhythm.
Lessons from the Kingdom
Today, Callie is aging gracefully—still shy, but calm, loved, and safe. She lives with Karen, but comes to stay with us whenever Karen is out of town. Amazingly, she’s happy in both homes now. She no longer hides. She no longer flinches. Her healing is visible and real.
Callie’s newfound confidence is visible
Bea, our fiery Queen, passed away last year from old age. But her last few years were happy and honored, filled with cuddles, sunshine, and love at Jo’s house. She ruled her final kingdom with dignity and—dare I say—joy.
And Homer? He’s still the quiet glue that holds it all together.
Homer and Callie, happy together at Mama Becker’s house or Karen’s house
What I Hope You’ll Take Away
If you’ve ever tried to force two animals to get along—especially when one is set in their ways—you know how exhausting and stressful it can be for everyone. Sometimes, despite your best intentions, peace just isn’t possible under one roof.
That doesn’t mean you’ve failed.
In our case, the answer wasn’t to “wait it out” or “let them work it out.” It was to listen. To observe. To recognize that separate happiness can yield more happiness.
And if you’re lucky enough to have family or friends willing to step in, a challenging situation can turn into something truly beautiful.
Bea and Callie taught us that even the fiercest Queens can thrive—when they’re given the right kind of kingdom.
With love, fur, and gratitude,
Mama Becker 🐾
15% OFF!
In honor of unavoidable stressors that sometimes occur in life, this week we’re offering 15% off our Stress Shaker that contains Chamomile, Rhodiola, and L-Theanine that can help promote calmness, balance, and tranquility.
Click here to grab yours (no code needed)
(Offer ends Monday, July 28th , 2025 at midnight)"